Will Deed vs. Gift Deed: Which Is Better for Property Transfer?

Transferring property within a family or to someone you trust can be done in multiple ways — but the two most common legal instruments in India are the Will Deed and the Gift Deed. While both allow you to transfer ownership of property, they work very differently in terms of timing, cost, and legal implications. Understanding these differences is crucial before you decide which one is best for your situation.

1. What Is a Will Deed?

A Will Deed is a legal document that declares how a person’s property will be distributed after their death. The person making the will is called the testator, and the person receiving the property is known as the beneficiary or legatee.

A Will can include not only immovable property (like land or houses) but also movable assets such as bank accounts, jewelry, or shares.

Key Features of a Will Deed:

• The Will comes into effect only after the death of the person who created it.

• It can be modified or canceled at any time during the testator’s lifetime.

• It requires no immediate transfer of ownership while the testator is alive.

• Registration of a Will is optional but highly recommended for authenticity.

Example:
If Mr. Sharma writes a Will stating that his flat will go to his daughter after his death, the transfer happens only after his lifetime — and he can change or cancel it anytime.

2. What Is a Gift Deed?

A Gift Deed is a legal document used to transfer ownership of property voluntarily and without any monetary consideration (i.e., without sale). It is often used to transfer property between close relatives such as parents and children, spouses, or siblings.

A Gift Deed must be executed during the lifetime of the donor (the giver) and accepted by the donee (the receiver).

Key Features of a Gift Deed:

• The transfer is immediate and irrevocable once executed and registered.

• It must be registered under Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

• Both the donor and donee must sign the document in the presence of two witnesses.

• The property is transferred out of love and affection, not for money.

Example:
If Mrs. Mehta gifts her son a house through a Gift Deed, ownership changes hands instantly after registration — and cannot be reversed later.

3. Key Differences Between Will Deed and Gift Deed

Aspect Will Deed Gift Deed When it takes effect After the death of the person Immediately upon registration Revocability Can be changed or canceled anytime Irrevocable once executed Ownership transfer Happens after the testator’s death Happens instantly Stamp duty Not applicable (only registration fee if registered) Stamp duty and registration fees apply Tax implications No tax at the time of Will execution Gift may be taxable if not to a relative Legal formalities Registration optional Registration mandatory Risk of misuse Lower, as property stays with owner till death Higher, as ownership is transferred immediately

4. Advantages of a Will Deed

• Control remains with you: You can enjoy and manage your property until your lifetime.

• Flexibility: You can modify or revoke the Will anytime if your preferences change.

• Cost-effective: No stamp duty is required, making it a cheaper option.

• Reduced disputes: A properly drafted Will ensures clarity and minimizes family disputes after your death.

However, a Will Deed only takes effect after your demise, and sometimes, it may be challenged in court if any family member disputes it.

5. Advantages of a Gift Deed

• Instant transfer of ownership: The property legally belongs to the receiver immediately.

• Legal validity: Registered Gift Deeds carry strong legal backing and are hard to challenge.

• Ideal for family transfers: Helps parents transfer property to children during their lifetime.

• Peace of mind: The donor can see the beneficiary enjoy the property while alive.

The only drawback is that a Gift Deed involves stamp duty and registration costs, which vary by state (usually between 2% and 7% of the property value). However, gifts to specified relatives (as defined under the Income Tax Act) are exempt from gift tax.

6. When Should You Choose a Will Deed?

A Will Deed is ideal if:

• You want to retain full control of your property during your lifetime.

• You wish to decide how your property should be distributed among heirs.

• You don’t want to incur stamp duty or registration costs.

• You want to avoid immediate transfer and keep the option to change beneficiaries later.

Example:
A senior citizen who wants to enjoy his property during his life and ensure it passes to his children after death should choose a Will Deed.

7. When Should You Choose a Gift Deed?

A Gift Deed is suitable if:

• You want to transfer property immediately during your lifetime.

• You wish to avoid inheritance disputes after your death.

• You want to see your loved ones use the property while you’re alive.

• You are transferring property to close relatives and can benefit from stamp duty concessions.

Example:
Parents gifting a house to their married daughter or son during their lifetime can use a Gift Deed for smooth and hassle-free transfer.

8. Legal and Tax Considerations

• Under the Income Tax Act, Section 56(2), gifts received from close relatives (spouse, parents, siblings, etc.) are not taxable, regardless of value.

• Gifts from non-relatives above ₹50,000 are treated as taxable income.

• Ensure the Gift Deed clearly mentions that the transfer is made out of love and affection to avoid any disputes.

• For a Will, registration is optional, but having it registered or attested by witnesses increases legal credibility.

9. Conclusion: Which Is Better?

Choosing between a Will Deed and a Gift Deed depends entirely on your personal goals and timing.

• Choose a Will Deed if you want to retain control over your property and transfer it only after your lifetime. It’s cost-effective, flexible, and ideal for estate planning.

• Choose a Gift Deed if you want to transfer ownership immediately to your loved ones and avoid future inheritance complications.

In simple terms:

A Will Deed secures your family’s future after your lifetime,
while a Gift Deed shares your wealth with them during your lifetime.

Before executing either, consult a property lawyer or legal expert to ensure compliance with local laws and to draft the deed accurately.

for more info on real estate investment please log in to our website flixahdeveloperspvtltd.com and you can also reach us at +91 9100600730